drobo-vs-synology

Drobo Vs Synology – Which One is Better?

Synology and Drobo have persistently ranked among the many greatest NAS equipment producers for the final couple of many years. In current years although, the reliability of Drobo’s merchandise appears to have dropped under par.

Since 2020, Drobo’s product lineup has diminished quite a bit. Drobo claimed this was on account of provide chain points brought on by COVID, and the product lineup can be restored once more quickly. However, as of 2022, issues have solely gotten worse. Drobo’s father or mother firm StorCentric filed for Chapter 11 chapter in July.

Considering the present state of Drobo, the query most individuals take into account is whether or not Drobo merchandise are ever price getting in comparison with Synology and different distributors. We’ll try to reply this query on this article.

Synology and Drobo Historically

Synology was based in 2000, whereas Drobo was based in 2005. Despite the late begin, Drobo rapidly gained reputation as its merchandise had been easy to make use of. Drobo’s proprietary RAID resolution (BeyondRAID) performed an enormous half on this, as did their {hardware}. However, this success didn’t final that lengthy.

While Synology continued innovating because it had all the time completed, Drobo remained largely stagnant. In reality, Drobo’s merchandise began to develop a status for being very liable to issues.

We’ve already talked about how Drobo has been having issue sustaining its product lineup. Add to that the monetary troubles, and it actually brings into query the already poor reliability of Drobo merchandise in the long run.

Drobo Vs Synology – Main Differences

Keeping all of the aforementioned issues in thoughts, we’ll attempt to cowl how Drobo at the moment compares to Synology by way of metrics like product lineup, capability, efficiency, and many others., and reply which one is best.

Product Selection

Drobo at the moment has two 2 DAS units (5C and 5D3), 1 SAN (B810i), and a pair of NAS home equipment (5N2 and B810n) in its lineup. We’ll focus on these units’ specs additional within the article, however for now, let’s simply say Drobo’s product choice is kind of a distinct segment for the time being.

drobo-products-lineup

Synology, then again, has expanded into numerous fields, from digicam and monitoring to routers and cloud options. Even if we discuss NAS and SANs particularly, Synology nonetheless will get a straightforward win with over 20 units on this class.

Rather than itemizing all of the merchandise right here, it could be higher to clarify Synology’s naming conference, as that’ll make it easier to acknowledge the units at a look. Synology calls their NAS units Disk Stations (DS). The final two digits within the title discuss with the discharge yr, whereas the remaining digits within the center point out what number of disks it might maintain.

For occasion, the DS 220+ launched in 2020 sports activities two drive bays. Let’s additionally have a look at a higher-end NAS like DS1621xs+. From the title, we will collect that it might maintain as much as 16 disks and was launched in 2021. Understanding this naming sample ought to assist you to find the form of machine you want from Synology’s in depth catalog.

Capacity

The 5C, 5D3, and 5N2 from Drobo can maintain as much as 5 HDDs. Similarly, the B810i and B810n sport 8 drive bays make them the best capability fashions that Drobo at the moment presents.

synology produts

Synology’s vary is far wider. They have single-bay worth choices just like the DS118, in addition to high-performance choices within the XS sequence. For occasion, the DS3622xs+ comes with 12 drive bays and might scale as much as 36 drives with enlargement items. 

Among enterprise NAS options, the RackStation RS4021xs+ is a high-end choice that comes with 16 bays and is scalable as much as 40 with enlargement items. For essentially the most demanding storage wants, Synology has 12-bay merchandise just like the SA3600 or SA3400, which might scale as much as 180 drives.

Performance

program loading bandwidth

The efficiency of a NAS/SAN machine is determined by numerous elements, from the disks used and the RAID sort to the community protocols, community velocity, and naturally, the enclosure’s specs. 

It’s onerous to make a one-on-one comparability in such circumstances, however if you happen to had been to pit related units (e.g., Drobo’s B810n towards Synology’s DS1821+), the efficiency can be comparable.

The distinction is available in the truth that Drobo at the moment has a really restricted product lineup suited to private use or small companies solely. Synology, then again, presents very high-end merchandise, which suggests it in the end wins by way of high-end efficiency as effectively.

Reliability

nas server rack

The reliability of any machine is difficult to gauge flatly, because it doesn’t simply rely upon construct high quality but in addition different dynamic elements like working circumstances. Data on actual failure charges is difficult to come back by as effectively. But judging from person studies, Drobo merchandise appear to have a significantly greater charge of failure.

And one would possibly argue that the true drawback comes after the machine fails. Unlike Synology, which is predicated on Linux’s mdadm utility, Drobo is a proprietary system. This signifies that within the case of failure, you’re fully reliant on the corporate’s help. Considering the below-par help expertise, so many Drobo customers have had, issues look grim.

In phrases of warranties, it’s greatest to have a look at particular person merchandise. Drobo merchandise typically include a 2-year commonplace guarantee. Synology is a little more versatile, with the guarantee interval starting from 1-5 years, relying on the product. Needless to say, higher-end merchandise just like the DS3622xs+ are backed by a better guarantee tier.

RAID

One essential issue when speaking about each the efficiency and reliability of units is the RAID model in use. Both Synology and Drobo help numerous RAID configurations, however in addition they have their very own proprietary RAID applied sciences.

raid-technology

Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR) manages a disk’s space for storing as smaller chunks. This maximizes the usable storage for redundancy whereas making certain minimal area is wasted in arrays with unequal disks. SHR usually offers one disk fault tolerance, whereas SHR-2 can maintain as much as two disk failures. This makes SHR wonderful by way of expandability.

Drobo focuses on forsaking the restrictions of conventional RAID and simplifying RAID implementation with BeyondRAID. BeyondRAID writes information on the block stage, implementing the very best RAID safety algorithm relying on the accessible information at any level. RAID administration can be very accessible, as you may merely insert new disks or exchange current ones.

User Interface

Synology’s merchandise are managed by DiskStation Manager (DSM), a web-based working system. On the opposite hand, Drobo’s merchandise are managed utilizing the Drobo Dashboard, which runs as an app on the present OS.

User-Interface

As a tailored OS, Synology DSM presents far more options and customization choices. This applies to the whole lot from personalization and bundle set up to RAID administration. DSM simply takes the cake by way of UI, however it’s nonetheless price mentioning that the Drobo Dashboard has seen appreciable enchancment in recent times.

Final Verdict – Drobo Vs Synology

It must be evident from all of the metrics we’ve lined up to now that Synology is just higher usually. Considering the present state of Drobo and the longer term, we extremely advocate going with Synology over Drobo. Before we finish, let’s go over the principle variations between Drobo vs Synology as soon as once more:

Drobo Synology
Product Lineup Only 5 merchandise at current Over 20 NAS and SAN merchandise to select from
Expandability Max 8 drive bays Products with as much as 40 drive bays and 180 disks (enlargement items required)
Performance Comparable efficiency with related spec units Wins by way of higher-end efficiency as Drobo doesn’t have same-tier merchandise
Reliability Devices are inclined to have a better failure charge Products are much less liable to failure, and the guarantee/help system can be higher
RAID Supports conventional RAID together with proprietary BeyondRAID Supports commonplace RAID ranges together with Synology Hybrid RAID (SHR)
UI Devices are managed by Drobo Dashboard  Devices are managed by Synology DiskStation Manager

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *